Stable Carbon Isotope Analysis Reveals Distinct Dietary Links to Added Sugar Intake in Children Versus Adults

PHILADELPHIA — A groundbreaking study emerging from the collaborative efforts of researchers at the Monell Chemical Senses Center and Temple University has recently shed new light on the complex relationship between nutritional biomarkers and added sugar intake, revealing marked differences between children and adults. This investigation utilized cutting-edge stable isotope analysis to unravel the nuanced dietary patterns across the lifespan, offering fresh perspectives that could reshape nutritional epidemiology and public health monitoring.

Added sugars remain a significant dietary concern in the United States, with consumption levels persistently exceeding federal guidelines. Excessive intake of these sugars has long been linked to a spectrum of chronic health issues, notably obesity and type 2 diabetes. However, accurately quantifying individual sugar consumption patterns poses substantial challenges, particularly in younger populations where dietary habits are rapidly evolving. Enter the innovative application of carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios (δ13C and δ15N), which have the potential to serve as objective biomarkers for added sugar intake.

The fundamental principle driving this research hinges upon the unique biochemical pathways involved in photosynthesis by corn and sugarcane, the predominant sources of added sugars in the American diet. Unlike many other plants, both corn and sugarcane utilize C4 photosynthesis, a process that results in characteristic elevations in the carbon isotope ratio (δ13C). Consequently, tissues that incorporate dietary carbon, such as blood and hair, reflect these isotopic signatures and therefore can be analyzed to infer the extent of added sugar consumption.

.adsslot_AlaRnNWkDJ{ width:728px !important; height:90px !important; }
@media (max-width:1199px) { .adsslot_AlaRnNWkDJ{ width:468px !important; height:60px !important; } }
@media (max-width:767px) { .adsslot_AlaRnNWkDJ{ width:320px !important; height:50px !important; } }

ADVERTISEMENT

Prior studies primarily focused on adults, particularly those residing in regions such as Alaska and Virginia, consistently demonstrated a direct association between elevated δ13C values in biological tissues and consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs) and other added sugar sources. These findings were further refined by integrating nitrogen isotope ratios (δ15N), which serve as proxies for protein intake, thereby controlling for dietary complexity. However, this robust biomarker validation was conspicuously absent for children, especially those under five years of age, a demographic characterized by markedly different nutritional profiles and metabolic dynamics.

Addressing this knowledge gap, the latest Monell-Temple study deployed a comprehensive cross-sectional design involving 138 children aged 3 to 11 years and their mothers to probe whether δ13C values in hair samples correspond with added sugar intake in both groups. Utilizing hair as a substrate offers temporal resolution since its growth rate (approximately 1 cm per month) allows dietary reconstruction over recent months. Alongside isotopic measurements, researchers meticulously collected 24-hour dietary recall data to rigorously quantify intake of foods and beverages containing added sugars, dairy, fruits, vegetables, and protein.

Intriguingly, results diverged sharply by age group. For adult participants, the established positive correlation between hair δ13C values and added sugar intake was reaffirmed, mirroring previous adult-focused research outcomes. Contrarily, in children, δ13C values failed to predict added sugar consumption, raising compelling questions about the underlying biological and dietary mechanisms that may differentially influence isotope incorporation across development stages.

To dissect these unexpected findings, the research team employed an innovative analytical framework borrowed from wildlife ecology: cluster analysis of combined δ13C and δ15N isotope values. This approach enabled the detection of natural groupings based on isotopic signatures, offering insights beyond simple linear regression models by capturing holistic dietary patterns. This nuanced methodology revealed that children in clusters marked by higher δ13C and δ15N values consumed significantly more cow’s milk than their counterparts in lower clusters.

This insight is critical because milk, a dietary staple in childhood, carries its own distinctive isotopic fingerprint that may confound the relationship between δ13C values and added sugar intake. Unlike adults, who typically consume fewer dairy products and more sugar-sweetened beverages, young children’s higher milk consumption appears to mask or dilute the isotopic signal associated with added sugars, thus obscuring the biomarker’s predictive utility within this age group.

The study authors propose that as children transition into adolescence, their dietary patterns evolve towards adult-like profiles, characterized by diminished milk consumption and increased intake of processed foods and sugary beverages. Such shifts potentially restore the coherence between δ13C isotopic signatures and added sugar intake, suggesting temporal windows during which isotope biomarkers’ accuracy varies significantly.

These revelations bear substantial implications for both research and public health practice. While carbon stable isotope analysis holds enormous promise as an objective dietary biomarker in adults, caution must be exercised when interpreting similar data in children, whose dietary complexity and growth dynamics may confound simple associations. The findings underscore the necessity of developing age-specific calibration models and considering entire dietary patterns rather than isolated nutrient metrics.

Jennifer O. Fisher, PhD, Associate Director of the Center for Obesity Research and Education at Temple University and coauthor of the study, emphasized this complexity by noting that stable isotope-based biomarkers in children might not deliver the straightforward interpretative clarity observed in adults. She highlighted the challenges posed by children’s diverse and evolving diets and the consequent need for a holistic analytical lens.

The research team advocates for further studies, particularly controlled feeding trials in young children, to delineate precisely how various foods and their isotopic compositions influence biological tissues during critical developmental windows. Such research is essential to refine these biomarkers for reliable use in pediatric nutritional surveillance and interventions.

Alissa D. Smethers, PhD, RD, the study’s first author and a registered dietitian, echoed the call for comprehensive, pattern-based approaches in pediatric nutrition research, cautioning against overly simplistic reliance on singular biomarkers like δ13C without contextualizing the broader diet. Her insights emphasize the intricacies of childhood nutrition assessment and the promise of multifaceted analytical strategies.

Funding for this pivotal study was supported by grants from the National Institute of Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, reflecting the interdisciplinary nature of nutritional biomarker research that intersects sensory science, metabolism, and public health. The full findings are detailed in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, with implications poised to influence future dietary monitoring frameworks.

As public health grapples with the persistent epidemic of diet-related diseases, innovative strategies like stable isotope analysis offer a promising frontier. However, this new evidence serves as a reminder that biological and behavioral variability, particularly in pediatric populations, demands sophisticated, nuanced methodologies to accurately decode the complex narrative of human nutrition.

Subject of Research: People

Article Title: Carbon stable isotope values in hair are associated with added sugar intake in adults but not young children: a cross-sectional study

News Publication Date: June 4, 2025

Web References:

Monell Chemical Senses Center – http://monell.org/
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition DOI – http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ajcnut.2025.02.013.

References:

Smethers, A. D., Menella, J. A., Fisher, J. O., Carney, E. M., & Coffman, D. L. (2025). Carbon stable isotope values in hair are associated with added sugar intake in adults but not young children: a cross-sectional study. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, [DOI:10.1016/j.ajcnut.2025.02.013].

Keywords: Health and medicine, Nutritional biomarkers, Stable isotope analysis, Added sugar intake, Childhood nutrition, Dietary assessment

Tags: added sugar intake biomarkersbiochemical pathways of photosynthesiscarbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratioschronic health issues from sugarcorn and sugarcane in dietdietary habits in younger populationsdietary patterns in children and adultsinnovative nutritional research methodsnutritional epidemiology researchobesity and type 2 diabetes linkspublic health monitoring strategiesstable carbon isotope analysis